Sarah McClure's February Blog Post Routman chapter 8: Teach Comprehension
I loved this chapter.
So often we get lost in the lists and details of strategy, strategy,
strategy, but neglect to explain the reason for the strategies in authentic
reading. Students learn all of these
strategies but don’t understand why and how to use them. . “Students don’t automatically comprehend
just because they can read the words.” (Routman pg. 121) Reading should be a
constant internal conversation between the reader and the text they are
reading. Even in the early years of
elementary education it is important to connect reading with comprehension as
opposed to just learning sight words. In
fourth grade, as Routman suggests, we teach comprehension through texts the
students are reading independently. We
also teach comprehension in conjunction with novel studies. It is important to not just teach strategies,
but to help students understand that proficient readers use them while reading
not just to get an answer right on an upcoming assessment, but to better
understand and interact with what they are reading. I agree that it is important to model
strategies with students and to share ways that I use strategies in my own free
time reading. I use rereading as a
strategy all of the time. Sharing this
with students gives credibility to the strategy. An integral part of all reading instruction
must be ample time to apply the learned strategies in a meaningful way.
Hi Sarah,
ReplyDeleteLike you, I loved this chapter. Routman's suggestions make so much sense to me. Why would we isolate comprehension strategies from decoding? She makes a valid point that if we aren't teaching reading for meaning, what good does it do when a student can decode but doesn't understand what they just read? I thought her suggestion of using student independent reading texts as possibilities for mini-lessons so then students can dive right back into their own book to try out the strategy(strategies) modeled.